Wondering how to start an alternative gift fair in your town? Pick a venue, recruit charities and volunteers, then follow a simple timeline. You can keep it small and still make it meaningful.
This guide belongs to a wider series on the lancaster alternative gift fair and how local fairs come together.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Optional planning timeline | Eight weeks, ideally starting in mid-October |
| Possible venues | Church, community center, school gym or office space |
| New Dream step-by-step guide published | October 15, 2013 |
| Lancaster fair debut | November 2008 |
| Lancaster fair timing (per a September 2014 post) | Saturday before Thanksgiving |
These figures come from New Dream’s step-by-step action kit and a Lancaster organizer’s 2014 post. They can change, so check the sources before you rely on them.
What an alternative gift fair is
An alternative gift fair gives people a way to skip the yearly stress of holiday shopping and the pile-up of “stuff”. Instead, they honor friends and relatives with donations to causes that fit their values, as the New Dream action kit explains.
The gifts themselves can take several forms. According to New Dream’s introductory action kit, they may include charitable donations, gently used secondhand items, help for a community project, and more.
Many of these gifts meet a direct, tangible need. The same kit gives examples such as medical supplies for refugees or food and clothing for local families in need.
Choose a venue and decide how big to go
You do not need a special building. The New Dream guide says a fair can be held anywhere from a local church or community center to a school gym or office space.
Size is flexible too. New Dream’s overview describes fairs that work for a few dozen people or a few hundred, so a first-time organizer can start small.
Settle these questions before you book anything:
- Which space can your group use easily, and does it have room for tables?
- How many charities can you host without crowding the room?
- How many volunteers can you realistically count on?
- Who is your audience: a congregation, a school, a workplace or the whole neighborhood?
Then pick your date. The Lancaster fair, for example, has been held on the Saturday before Thanksgiving, according to the organizer’s post of September 3, 2014. It helps to look at what else is on the calendar, and these lancaster pa christmas events show how busy a local season can get.
Recruit charities and volunteers
The fair only works if there is something meaningful on the tables. The New Dream guide describes a fair featuring local and international charities that are working to make the world a better place, and it provides resources on soliciting participating organizations, assembling volunteers and setting up the fair.
When you invite a charity, it helps to have clear answers to a few things:
- What exactly does a gift pay for, in plain words?
- How will the giver receive a card or note to hand to the person being honored?
- Who will staff the charity’s table on the day?
- How does the donation reach the charity afterward?
Mixing local and faraway causes gives guests more to choose from. Someone shopping for a neighbor may want a local food program, while someone shopping for a relative may prefer an international project.
Volunteers can cover registration, setup, greeting and cleanup. Give each person one clear job so they know where to stand and what to say.
Build your planning timeline
The New Dream guide offers an optional eight-week timeline for planning the event, ideally starting in mid-October, according to its action kit page. You can use that as a model or shrink it to suit a smaller event.
Whatever length you choose, the order of work tends to look like this:
- Choose a date and confirm the venue.
- Invite charities and collect their details.
- Recruit volunteers and assign jobs.
- Plan extras such as food, fair trade vendors and activities for kids.
- Spread the word to your chosen audience.
- Set up the room, run the fair and thank everyone afterward.
When you are ready to track each task, the alternative gift fair checklist is a handy companion to this outline.
Add food, fair trade and kids’ activities
Jenn Knepper, who founded the Lancaster fair, shared tips in her September 3, 2014 post. Her first suggestion for atmosphere is food: bringing in food vendors makes for a more festive event.
She also suggests fair trade items as an accompaniment to the alternative gifts. Her fair featured booths from businesses such as Canaan Fair Trade Olive Oil and Singing Rooster Haitian Coffee, as the same post describes.
For families, she recommends free kids’ activities. That year’s stations let children roll beads, make handmade cards, and write letters of encouragement to active service members, retired veterans, wounded warriors and sick children.
The post also recommends working with existing organizations that can come in and offer these activities. It calls this a good way for groups to make connections and build community.

Lessons from the first Lancaster fair
Knepper’s story began when she read about a Harrisburg, Pennsylvania-based women’s giving circle that was putting together an alternative gift fair. She contacted the group and decided to replicate the idea in Lancaster, per her 2014 post.
The Lancaster fair debuted in November 2008. As of that September 2014 post, it had been held on the Saturday before Thanksgiving every year since.
Her tone is a useful model. She wrote that the aim is not to be scrooges who say “bah humbug” to all gifts, but to help people put more thought into what they give.
The practical lesson is to borrow from people who have done it before. Ask local groups what worked, then adapt it to your own community.
Frequently asked questions
How long does it take to plan a fair?
Show answer
The New Dream guide includes an optional eight-week planning timeline, ideally starting in mid-October. A smaller event may need less, but a clear schedule helps either way.
Do I need a large venue?
Show answer
No. The guide lists a church, community center, school gym or office space as possible settings. Choose the space that fits your charities and your crowd.
Does an alternative gift fair mean giving up ordinary gifts?
Show answer
Not necessarily. Knepper wrote in her 2014 post that the goal is to help people think more about their gifts, not to say “bah humbug” to all of them.
Can other products be sold at the fair?
Show answer
Some organizers add them. The same post suggests including fair trade items alongside the alternative gifts, and it also mentions food vendors.
What counts as an alternative gift?
Show answer
According to New Dream, examples include charitable donations, gently used secondhand items and help for a community project.



