You want to give something that matters, not another sweater. So how do alternative gift fairs work? You pick a gift that supports a cause, then give it to a loved one in their name.
This guide is part of a wider look at alternative gift ideas.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Lancaster fair first held | November 2008 |
| Usual date, per a September 2014 post | Saturday before Thanksgiving |
| Idea borrowed from | A Harrisburg, Pennsylvania women’s giving circle |
| Example gift | A year of education for a girl in Africa, given in a parent’s name |
| Fair trade booths named | Canaan Fair Trade Olive Oil; Singing Rooster Haitian Coffee |
| Kids’ activities | Rolling beads, handmade cards, letters of encouragement |
These figures come from a September 2014 post by the Lancaster fair’s founder on New Dream’s blog. Dates, vendors and activities can change, so check the source and the organiser’s own page before you rely on them.
The basic idea: giving in someone’s name
An alternative gift fair replaces a shopping trip with a gift made in someone’s name. Instead of a tie or a sweater, you choose a cause and give it to a loved one in their honor.
The point is not to scold anyone. The founder of the Lancaster fair wrote that it is not her group’s intention to be scrooges about gifts, and that the goal is to help people put more thought into what they give, because “buying more stuff doesn’t signify more love” (New Dream).
The test she suggests is to ask what the person really cares about. In her words: “What is it that Aunt Barb or Teacher Jane really cares about?” A separate guide explains what is an alternative gift fair in plain terms.
What happens at a fair?
Details differ from one fair to the next, but the Lancaster example gives a clear picture. A visit mixes gift choosing with a festive day out.
- Think about the person you are giving to and what they care about.
- Choose a gift that supports a cause, such as a girl’s education.
- Give it in the person’s name instead of handing over an object.
- Stay for the booths, food and activities around the gifts.
The founder’s own example shows the idea. Her parents kept saying they did not want more stuff, so she gave them a gift that provides a year of education in their name to a young girl in Africa (New Dream). How gifts are paid for and presented varies, so check the organiser’s page before you go.

Fair trade, food and kids’ activities around the gifts
The gifts are only part of the day. The founder advises hosts to add fair trade items alongside the alternative gifts, and her fair features booths such as Canaan Fair Trade Olive Oil and Singing Rooster Haitian Coffee (New Dream).
Food adds to the mood. She writes that bringing in food vendors makes for a more festive event, and that her fair has always offered a wide variety of flavors from around the world. In the year of the post, 2014, it also partnered with a local cultural group that hosts a “Taste the World” walking tour of Lancaster (New Dream).
Free kids’ activities keep families involved. At the stations described in the post, children can:
- roll beads;
- make handmade cards;
- write letters of encouragement to active service members, retired veterans, wounded warriors and sick children.
The post recommends working with existing organizations that can come in and run these activities, and calls it a great way for groups to make connections and build community.
How the Lancaster fair began
The founder read a newspaper article headlined “Your Grandmother Doesn’t Need Another Sweater and Your Dad Doesn’t Need Another Tie.” It described a Harrisburg giving circle that was putting together an alternative gift fair as one of its holiday projects, and she decided to replicate it in Lancaster (New Dream).
The Lancaster Alternative Gift Fair debuted in November 2008. As of that September 2014 post, it had been held on the Saturday before Thanksgiving every year since. Confirm the current date with the organisers, because it may have changed.
She worked with an umbrella organization that provides resources and tools for people who want to host their own fair. The post also points hosts to New Dream’s step-by-step guide and recorded webinar. This site is independent and is not affiliated with any of these groups.
Making a fair gift feel personal
A fair gift works best when it matches the person. A few habits help:
- Start from what the person cares about, not from the cause you like best.
- Add a short note that says why you chose it.
- Pair the gift with something small and shared, such as fair trade coffee from a booth.
For more ways to honor someone with a donation, read about charity gifts in honor of someone.
Frequently asked questions
Do alternative gift fairs replace all other gifts?
Show answer
No. The Lancaster founder wrote that the aim is not to say “bah humbug” to all gifts, but to help people think harder about what they give to loved ones.
What can you find at a fair besides gifts?
Show answer
The Lancaster example includes fair trade booths, food vendors and free kids’ activities, according to the founder’s 2014 post on New Dream’s blog.
When is the Lancaster fair held?
Show answer
As of the September 2014 post, it was held on the Saturday before Thanksgiving. Check with the organisers for the current date.
Can you host your own fair?
Show answer
The founder says yes, and suggests using New Dream’s guide and webinar, adding fair trade items, bringing in food and offering free kids’ activities. This site does not offer hosting help or consulting.



