Tired of buying another sweater nobody needs? The best alternative gift ideas swap clutter for a donation, a fair trade item or a handmade piece tied to a cause your recipient cares about.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Nonprofits at a Lancaster, PA alternative gift fair (2016) | 30 local and global organizations |
| Donation-based gifts offered by each nonprofit (2016) | 3 gifts |
| Fair attendance reported by its organizer (2016) | Over 1000 people |
| Average U.S. holiday spending, as quoted by that organizer (2016) | $800 |
| Nonprofits signed up for the same fair (2024) | More than three dozen |
These figures come from SEE Change Magazine (November 2016) and One United Lancaster (November 2024). They can change from year to year, so check the sources before you rely on them.
What counts as an alternative gift?
An alternative gift is a present whose value goes beyond the object itself. It might be a donation made in someone’s name, a fair trade item or something handmade by an artisan, given instead of another trinket, sweater or candle.
Most ideas fall into a few families:
- Donation gifts: a contribution to a cause, made in a loved one’s name.
- Symbolic gifts: a catalog item, such as a farm animal for a community in need, that stands for a donation.
- Fair trade goods: chocolate, olive oil, jewelry and other products sold to support the people who made them.
- Handmade items: pieces crafted by artisans or by people building work experience.
- Time and skills: an offer to volunteer with a nonprofit the recipient admires.
If the idea is new to you, read what is an alternative gift fair for a plain-language explainer of the event format. A separate guide to the symbolic gifts charity catalog explains how those catalog items work.
Time can be a gift too. The organizer of a Lancaster fair told SEE Change Magazine in 2016 that shoppers can also connect with organizations that need volunteer help.
Donation gifts given in someone’s honor
The best-known version is the charity gift catalog. In a New Dream post from May 2017, a fair is described as essentially a live version of a charity gift catalog, with nonprofits hosting the tables.
The post names Heifer International as a familiar example, where you can honor a loved one by gifting a needy community a cow. You give to the cause, and the person you honor learns about it instead of unwrapping an object.
Gifts in the Lancaster fair’s 2016 interview included a few concrete examples:
- A cow given to Heifer International.
- Books for the Reach Out and Read program.
- Support for mothers enrolled in Nurse Family Partnership.
- Bikes for World Bicycle Relief.
Those examples come from the organizer’s interview with SEE Change Magazine. For wording ideas and etiquette, see the guide to charity gifts in honor of someone.
In its November 2024 report, One United Lancaster said visitors to that year’s fair could give on behalf of friends and family, who would receive gift cards acknowledging the contribution. That small card is what turns a donation into a gift you can hand over.

Fair trade and handmade gifts that support makers
Not every thoughtful gift is a donation. Many fairs also run a marketplace of fair trade and social enterprise goods, so you can hand someone a real object that still does good.
The 2016 interview named Bead for Life handmade jewelry, Divine Chocolate and Canaan Fair Trade Olive Oil as fair trade gifts at a Lancaster fair, per SEE Change Magazine. The organizer also said social enterprises help people who would otherwise face barriers to employment gain job experience and earn wages.
The New Dream post adds local examples: Light on a Hill Candles, made by women transitioning out of prison, and Revolution jewelry, made out of recycled leather by women experiencing homelessness. It also notes that several food vendors at that fair were social enterprises that employ refugees.
For product ideas by price and occasion, browse fair trade gift ideas. If you prefer one-of-a-kind pieces, see handmade gifts that support artisans.

How alternative gift fairs work in practice
A fair puts many causes under one roof, so you can compare them and shop in a single visit. A long-running Lancaster fair gives a concrete picture, and you can read the general mechanics in how do alternative gift fairs work.
The organizer told SEE Change Magazine that the first Lancaster event was held in November 2008. By 2016 the fair listed 30 local and global nonprofits, each offering three donation-based gifts, and the organizer reported over 1000 visitors and free entry.
The same interview describes the aim as an alternative to holiday consumerism. The organizer quoted an average American holiday spend of $800 and said fairgoers can find meaning-filled gifts for everyone on a list.
By One United Lancaster’s November 2024 report, the fair had reached its 17th annual edition, with more than three dozen nonprofits signed up. It ran from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. on Sunday, Dec. 1, 2024, at the Farm & Home Center, and included food trucks, a fair trade marketplace and a Human Rights Day scavenger hunt. That year’s date was also “Secondhand Sunday,” which encourages people to consider used and vintage gift items and embrace sustainable shopping practices.
To plan a visit, see the lancaster alternative gift fair overview. For other ways to help nearby, read giving back in lancaster pa.

Shopping a fair step by step
A fair can feel busy, so a simple routine helps you leave with gifts you feel good about.
- Write a short list of the people you are shopping for and what each cares about.
- Walk the nonprofit tables first and ask what each gift pays for.
- Match each person to a cause, then choose the gift that fits the cause.
- Collect the gift card or note that tells the recipient what the donation does.
- Finish in the marketplace for a fair trade or handmade item to go with it.
The Lancaster layout described by New Dream follows that flow: the nonprofits with alternative gifts in one room and a separate room with fair trade and social enterprise gifts. Fairs elsewhere may be organized differently.
Alternative gifts for Christmas, weddings and other occasions
The idea fits almost any occasion because you choose the cause to suit the person. For December, christmas gifts that give back covers ways to replace the usual pile of presents without leaving anyone empty-handed.
Couples who already have a full kitchen sometimes ask guests to give to a cause instead. The page on alternative wedding gift ideas donation walks through how to word that request kindly.
Timing can add meaning. The New Dream post advises looking for community or international events that coincide with your mission, and describes a 2016 fair that fell on Human Rights Day, commemorating the signing of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights on December 10, 1948.
How to choose a cause and a charity
The cause matters more than the price tag. One organizer wrote in 2017 that she now gives her parents annual gifts that support the education of young women in parts of the world where they historically are hindered or restricted from school, according to New Dream.
Local needs are a good place to start. A Lancaster fair’s organizer listed issues like literacy, access to healthy food, education, housing and prevention of abuse in the SEE Change interview.
Before you give, run through a short check:
- What exactly does the gift pay for?
- Does the cause connect to something the recipient cares about?
- Can you meet or ask the organization questions, as you can at a fair?
- Will the recipient know what you gave and why?
A fuller checklist is in how to choose a charity to give to.
Frequently asked questions
Are alternative gifts only for Christmas?
Show answer
No. The Lancaster fair above was held on Sunday, Dec. 1 in 2024, but One United Lancaster reported in November 2024 that its organizer also runs an online site where gifts can be purchased year-round.
What does the recipient actually receive?
Show answer
Usually a card or note that explains the donation. As of One United Lancaster’s November 2024 report, visitors to that fair could give on behalf of friends and family, who received gift cards acknowledging the contribution. Pairing it with a small fair trade item gives them something to hold.
How much should I spend?
Show answer
The sources set no price. The organizer in the 2016 SEE Change interview quoted $800 as the average American holiday spend, but you can pick any amount that suits your budget and the cause.
Can I start a fair in my own town?
Show answer
The New Dream post from May 2017 says it does not have to be big or grand, and to start at a pace and size manageable for your team. It describes a Lancaster planning team of about 12 people meeting monthly.



