Plain-language guides to lancaster alternative gift fairs

Search

Symbolic Charity Gifts Explained: Goats, Trees, School Supplies

symbolic gifts charity catalog

Wondering what you actually get when you buy a goat for someone? A symbolic gifts charity catalog lets you give in a loved one’s name, but your money usually goes into a pool of funds for similar projects, not a specific animal.

If you are weighing up gifts that do good, this guide sits alongside our broader collection of alternative gift ideas.

Item Value
Goat gift (World Vision NZ listing) $50
Chicken and feed (World Vision NZ listing) $12
Help a girl get an education (World Vision NZ listing) $80
Goat gift (Oxfam, as reported in 2015) 25 pounds
Bag of cement (WaterAid, as reported in 2015) $15

Prices come from World Vision NZ’s catalogue page and a Reuters report published by VOA. Catalogue figures can change, so check the source before you rely on them.

How a symbolic charity gift works

You browse a catalog of items such as a goat, a chicken or tree seedlings, pay the listed price and give the recipient a card saying a gift was made in their name. World Vision NZ says each gift comes with a Printed Card or eCard, and you pick which one, as described on its catalogue page.

The process is simple:

  1. Choose an item that suits the person or the cause.
  2. Pay the listed price, which goes to the charity.
  3. Pick a printed card or an eCard to send to the recipient.
  4. The charity spends the money on projects in that area, such as family income, education or health.

The gift is a symbol of that work. World Vision NZ describes each item as representing projects it runs with communities, so the goat on the page stands for farming and income support rather than a single animal with your name on it.

What typical gifts cost

Prices vary by charity, currency and year, so treat these as examples rather than a price list. Each figure below carries the date or source it came from.

  • World Vision NZ’s catalogue page lists a goat at $50, a chicken and feed at $12, a family vege garden at $28 and help for a girl’s education at $80.
  • A Reuters report on VOA from December 24, 2015 gave Oxfam prices of 25 pounds for a goat (about $37 at the time), 9 pounds for a pile of manure and 32 pounds for solar energy equipment.
  • The same report put WaterAid’s gifts at a $15 bag of cement up to a $55 hand pump.
  • A PBS Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly segment from December 13, 2008 listed school supplies at $25 per classroom and a can of worms at 18 dollars for one pound.

Will the goat you buy actually be delivered?

Usually not. The 2015 Reuters report on VOA found that donations are not earmarked for a particular gift but go into a pool of funds that charities spend according to needs.

Oxfam’s Unwrapped manager, Lindsey Bassett, said the money from selling goats is spent on projects that help people earn an income, put food on the table and cope with climate change. She said that flexibility gets money to where it is needed most, as quickly as possible, according to the same report.

WaterAid’s John Gray gave the practical reason: delivering individual goats or bags of cement is too complex and costly. Instead, a cement gift funds the purchase of cement for toilet blocks somewhere in the world, as quoted in the VOA piece.

This is not new. A PBS segment from December 2008 noted that the charities say the happy pictures are just symbolic, and that what a gift buys depends on what is most needed at the time.

symbolic gifts charity catalog Cupped seedling
Two hands cup dark soil with a small green seedling.

What goats, trees and school supplies stand for

Each popular item points to a type of project. Here is how the sources describe them:

  • Goats and chickens: World Vision NZ says a goat gives a family milk for nutrition and extra income, plus offspring they can sell for school fees and healthcare, as set out on its catalogue page.
  • Tree seedlings: the same page groups these under environment gifts, which cover tree seedlings, reviving a forest or training in climate-smart farming.
  • School supplies: PBS listed these at $25 per classroom in its December 2008 segment, while World Vision NZ’s education gifts aim to keep children in school with books and fees covered.

Charities also build in a safety valve. World Vision NZ says that if a community is gifted more chickens than it needs, it will use the donation to tackle similar, urgent problems children face, per its catalogue page.

How do you choose a gift that fits the person?

Start with what the recipient cares about, then check how the charity handles the money. A few quick checks help:

  • Read the small print to see whether gifts are pooled or tied to a specific item.
  • Match the theme, such as animals, trees or schooling, to the recipient’s interests.
  • Compare prices and what each gift covers across more than one charity.
  • Decide whether a printed card or an eCard suits the occasion.

Before you pay, it helps to read about how to choose a charity to give to. If the occasion is a celebration, our guide to alternative wedding gift ideas donation shows how couples ask guests to give this way.

Frequently asked questions

Does the person I give to receive a goat?

Show answer

No. As the 2015 Reuters report on VOA explains, your donation joins a pool of funds spent on projects where it is needed most. The recipient gets a card describing the gift.

Can I send a card with the gift?

Show answer

Yes. World Vision NZ says each gift comes with a Printed Card or eCard that you pick and personalise, as stated on its catalogue page.

Why does a goat cost different amounts at different charities?

Show answer

Charities, currencies and years differ. World Vision NZ lists a goat at $50 on its catalogue page. A report dated December 24, 2015 gave Oxfam’s goat as 25 pounds, while PBS called a goat at $75 the most popular item in December 2008.

What happens if a charity raises more than a gift needs?

Show answer

It redirects the extra to similar needs. World Vision’s gift catalog director said in the 2015 report that instead of a goat, the funds would purchase a cow.