Plain-language guides to lancaster alternative gift fairs

Search

How to Choose a Charity: Checking Ratings and Transparency

how to choose a charity to give to

You want your gift to matter, but every charity sounds good. Here is how to choose a charity to give to: check its website, its financials and an independent rating before you donate.

If you are building a gift list, the wider range of alternative gift ideas shows where a charity donation fits.

Item Value
BBB Charity Standards used to evaluate charities 20 standards
BBB standard on charity website content Standard 17: mission, board roster, past-year program summary and financial information including the latest IRS Form 990
BBB standard on donor privacy Standard 18: a clear privacy policy
CharityWatch “highly efficient” level, as of a 2017 article At least 75 percent of budget spent on charitable programs

These figures come from the BBB Wise Giving Alliance’s March 2026 website guidance and a 2017 Northwestern Mutual article. Standards and benchmarks can change, so check the source before you rely on them.

Decide what you want your gift to do

Before you compare ratings, decide where you want your money to land. A November 2024 blog post from Bellwether credit union frames the first choice as local, national or international giving.

The same post says local groups are often very efficient with spending, and that you can see the results in your own community. National and global charities may have more reach, but they also need a closer look at how they report their work.

Not every gift has to be a cheque or a card payment. If you want a keepsake that carries a donation, the symbolic gifts charity catalog explains how those gifts work. If you would rather give something made by a person, read about handmade gifts that support artisans.

Confirm the charity is a real nonprofit

Start with status. The Bellwether post says to make certain the organization is a certified 501(c)(3) non-profit, and that only donations to registered 501(c)(3) nonprofits are eligible for a tax deduction.

That advice describes the United States. If you give somewhere else, look for your own country’s charity register instead.

The same post suggests a simple order of checks:

  1. Look for the charity’s 501(c)(3) certificate and tax ID number, which should also be on its website.
  2. Search for it on the BBB Wise Giving Alliance, the IRS charity search tool, Charity Navigator, Guidestar and Charity Watch.
  3. Click through from its social media to its website and see whether the details hold up.

If a charity seems to exist in a black hole with no solid public information, the Bellwether post warns that it might not be on the up-and-up.

What should you look for on a charity’s website?

A charity’s website is often the first place donors go. The BBB Wise Giving Alliance’s March 2026 guidance says robust website materials are a positive sign of a transparent, trustworthy organization, and that Standard 17 of its accountability standards sets out what a site should include.

  • A clear mission statement that says what the charity actually does.
  • A roster of the board.
  • A summary of the past year’s program activities.
  • Financial information, including access to the most recent IRS Form 990, as the BBB guidance describes.
how to choose a charity to give to Laptop research
A seated person rests a laptop on their lap with one hand near the trackpad.

Pay special attention to the money pages. The BBB guidance says to look for complete Form 990s or audited financial statements rather than brief summaries, and to proceed with caution if they are hard to find.

Houses of worship and their affiliated entities are not required to file a Form 990, according to the same BBB guidance. Their pages may look different for that reason.

Also read the privacy policy. BBB Charity Standard 18 calls for a clear policy explaining what information a charity collects, how it is used, how you can update or limit it, and how it is protected, as the BBB guidance explains.

Use ratings and watchdog reports

You do not have to judge a charity alone. Consumer Reports’ advice, last updated on November 22, 2019, is to check the charity with one or more watchdogs, including the BBB Wise Giving Alliance, Charity Navigator and CharityWatch, in its guide to charity donations.

A 2017 Northwestern Mutual article describes how the three differ:

  • The BBB Wise Giving Alliance accredits charities based on 20 standards.
  • Charity Navigator rates charities on financial health, accountability and transparency.
  • CharityWatch publishes ratings, plus news stories and analyst’s notes about the charities it evaluates.

If the charity you care about is not on the BBB list, the BBB Wise Giving Alliance says you can ask it for a report through its charity inquiry page, and it will do its best to produce one.

Do not pick by the name alone. In the Consumer Reports guide, a BBB Wise Giving Alliance executive says you do not want to choose a charity that way, since your donation may go to a questionable group.

Read the overhead numbers with care

Many charities advertise a percentage that goes to programs, and the wording matters. The Northwestern Mutual article explains that a claim of 90 percent of every dollar donated going to programs does not necessarily mean 90 percent of the budget is spent on the cause and just 10 percent on overhead and fundraising.

To get a truer picture, the article says to look for wording about every dollar spent, not donated. That is because some charities also earn income from investments or in-kind gifts, so cash donations may be only a fraction of their revenue.

As a benchmark, the same 2017 article says CharityWatch considers a charity “highly efficient” when it spends at least 75 percent of its budget on charitable programs. Treat that as one data point, not a verdict, and weigh it alongside transparency and the kind of work the charity does.

Whatever the percentage, the Bellwether post says a charity unwilling to share how donations are spent versus covering overhead is a red flag.

Frequently asked questions

Is a charity’s name enough to trust it?

Show answer

No. The Consumer Reports guide, updated on November 22, 2019, warns against choosing by name alone and recommends checking one or more watchdogs first.

Do all charities file a Form 990?

Show answer

Not all. The BBB Wise Giving Alliance’s March 2026 guidance notes that houses of worship and their affiliated entities are not required to file an IRS Form 990.

What does “highly efficient” mean for a charity?

Show answer

In a 2017 Northwestern Mutual article, CharityWatch considers a charity highly efficient when it spends at least 75 percent of its budget on charitable programs. It is one benchmark among several.

What should I do if a charity has little public information?

Show answer

Treat it as a warning sign. The Bellwether post from November 2024 says a charity with no solid public information might not be on the up-and-up, so look for a more open alternative.